Extra Space Storage Inc.

EXR
Real Estate
$154.91
2.98%Overvalued

Extra Space Storage Inc. (EXR) is a Real Estate company that currently yields 2.98% — historically overvalued based on 10 years of dividend yield history. The Weiss valuation model places the undervaluation threshold at $89.07 and the overvaluation threshold at $158.74. Extra Space Storage Inc. holds a quality score of 10/100 (Risky), reflecting 14 consecutive years of dividend growth with a 132% payout ratio. The 5-year dividend CAGR stands at -13.6%.

EXR Dividend Yield History — Weiss Valuation

Underval. $89.07Overval. $158.74

Distance to undervalued

Entry price is stretched

Needs 42.5% downside to reach the Weiss buy zone

Undervaluation starts near $89.07, where the annual dividend would imply roughly 5.19% yield. That is 2.20% above today's yield.

Buy-zone price

$89.07

Target yield

5.19%

Research checklist

What to clear before buying the yield

Updated Nov 22, 2026

Dividend durability

14Y

Long dividend history supports a deeper look.

Earnings payout

132%

Coverage deserves a closer look in filings.

Cash payout

85%

Free cash flow coverage supports the payment.

Dividend growth

-13.6%

Lower growth changes the return trade-off.

What changed

What changed since the last update

2026-11-21 → 2026-11-22

No major change in signal, yield, price, quality, or payout since the last update.

Why Now?

Extra Space Storage Inc. is trading near its historical overvaluation band.

Current yield 3.0% vs historical max 5.1% (59% of maximum).

Recent dividend history shows no sustained growth streak.

Elevated payout ratio of 132%.

What matters now

Read the signal before the headline yield

Valuation is the brake here: the yield is compressed versus its own history.

The 10/100 quality score says the headline yield needs extra skepticism.

The earnings payout ratio is above 100%, so coverage is the first risk to unpack.

EXR Dividend Income Projection — DRIP Compounder

Dividend Compounder (DRIP)

$

Year 1 Income

$298

Year 10 Income

$389

Yield on Cost

4%

Total Income

$3,416

Assumes dividends reinvested at current price. Simplified model — for illustrative purposes only.

Track actual vs. projected

See what EXR dividends you actually received with Sharesight

Dividend income log · Yield on cost · DRIP cost basis · Tax reports

→

More research

Full price history & technical analysis

TradingView ↗

Fundamentals, valuation & analyst ratings

FinViz ↗

Moat rating & analyst fair value

Morningstar ↗

Track dividends received & tax reports

Sharesight ↗

EXR Dividend Quality Score

Quality Score

10/ 100

Risky

Payout Ratio0/25
Dividend Streak0/25
Growth (CAGR 5Y)0/20
Yield vs History5/15
FCF Coverage5/15

Key Metrics

Current Price$154.91
Annual Dividend$4.62
Current Yield2.98%
Yield — Max (10Y)5.08%
Yield — Min (10Y)3.09%
Undervalued Below$89.07
Overvalued Above$158.74
Payout Ratio131.71%
CAGR Dividend 5Y-13.6%
CAGR Dividend 10Y1.1%
Years No Cut—

Invest in EXR

Check Extra Space Storage Inc. availability and current costs on eToro

Check eToro terms and availability →
Fractional sharesFees vary by countryCapital at risk

DividendVisual may earn a commission if you open an account via this link, at no cost to you. Capital at risk. Not financial advice.

14
consecutive years of dividend growth